There’s no better feeling than having warm, dry feet in cold, miserable weather. That’s why having a capable pair of winter boots is so important. The best winter boots should keep you just as warm and dry commuting in the city as they do on rugged terrain during a snow-filled hike in the woods.
We spent nearly three months bundled up in a warm winter coat so that we could research and test 10 pairs of winter boots to tell you that the Sorel Women’s Caribou Boot (available at Amazon) is the one to get. Its balance of superior waterproofing, warmth and a timeless, cute style won both our hearts and our tests.
If you spend a lot of time walking in the cold, the Muck Boots Arctic Ice Tall (available at Amazon) is also a fine choice. They’re incredibly comfortable, warm, and made to protect your feet from the ice, slush, and snow. Whether you're shoveling deep snow in your driveway or just walking your dog on an icy street, Reviewed has you covered.
Here are the best winter boots for women we tested ranked, in order:
- Sorel Women’s Caribou Boots
- Muck Boots Women’s Arctic Ice Tall
- UGG Women’s Adirondack III Boots
- Sorel Women’s Joan of Arctic Boots
- Timberland Women’s Jayne Waterproof Fleece Fold-Down Boots
- Columbia Women’s Ice Maiden II Boots
- L.L.Bean Women’s Bean Boots, 10” Shearling-Lined
- L.L.Bean Women’s Bean Boots, 8” Thinsulate
- The North Face Women’s Thermoball Lace Up
- Sperry Women’s Maritime Repel Snow Boot w/Thinsulate
Our Favorite Winter Boots For Women of 2021
BEST OVERALL
Sorel Women's Caribou Boots
Pros
- Removable liner
- Sturdy rubber sole
- High-quality insulation
Cons
BEST FOR ALL-DAY WEAR
Muck Boot Women's Arctic Ice Tall Boots
Pros
- Comfortable
- Excellent ice traction
- Breathable
Cons
BEST OVERALL
Sorel Women's Caribou Boots
The Sorel Women’s Caribou boots were the best women’s winter boots that we tested. With their superior insulation and sturdy rubber sole, they yielded the best results of every boot that we called in for testing. The Caribous are instantly comfortable and keep your feet warm without overheating, protecting your feet in temperatures as low as -40 degrees Fahrenheit. They’re perfect for heavy snow and are stylish enough to wear on your daily commute. Featuring a synthetic fleece-trimmed cuff, they’re available in black, tan, and grey.
During testing, the Caribous provided excellent traction on ice. The seam-sealed leather upper kept my feet bone dry and the vulcanized rubber shell covering the bottom half of the boot offering excellent protection against deep snow and heavy slush. The best part? The Caribou’s removable recycled felt liners can be swapped out if they get wet, left out to dry, and are replaceable if they wear out. Our testing suggests that you should go a half size up from your regular shoe size when buying these boots, as the Caribou run short and wide.
The only downside to these is that they’re a bit bulky, which could make taking the stairs or driving difficult.
BEST FOR ALL-DAY WEAR
Muck Boot Women's Arctic Ice Tall Boots
The Muck Arctic Ice Tall boots proved to be the most comfortable boot to wear during testing, out of all of the ones we tested. This came as no surprise, given the bootmaker’s reputation for making crazy comfortable, waterproof footwear. I found that they offered excellent ice traction, breathability, and waterproofing. Despite their rubberized lower, these boots stretched out nicely, to conform with my feet while I was wearing them. They provide good arch support, thanks to their comfortable insoles. That said, it’s also possible to add your own insole or orthotic, to them.
At 17.5 inches tall, the Arctic Ice Tall boots are well suited for stomping around in the mud, puddles, or deep snow. They are made of one hundred percent waterproofed rubber with a neoprene and synthetic fleece lining that keeps your feet warm in temperatures that range between -58 to 30 degrees Fahrenheit. During the hike, these boots kept my balance steady and my feet secure, even on slippery ice.
These are a great choice if you’re looking for something sporty and easy to pull on and off. A shaft circumference of 16-inches allowed these boots to glide down my legs, and I have thick calves! The Arctic Ice Tall has a simple design that makes them stylish as well as functional. Be sure to size up if you’re interested in a pair of the Arctic Ice Tall as they only come in whole sizes. If I had sized down, the boots would have been too tight in the toe box.
Post a Comment